I think that this is a good update, was initially hesitant as I was holding out for campaign expansion not just a ship pack, but the ships are truely different and interesting and the DLC isn't greedily priced. In practice I think I like the Cylon ships better than the colonial ones in this pack, while true both sides seem to have a new ship that's an odd build off of an existing one and one truely original I just find the Cerastes more useful than any of the others. I do like the Phobos as well, its basically a Nemisis that has fighters. The Berzerk is essentially the Ademant without missiles and less Armor but way more firepower, I don't see it as strong enough to really be a ship of the line like the Ademant so I guess its best used as a support vessle under the protection of a battlestar's flack screen. I have not used the Janus that much but it really seems like the colonial counterpart to a Cylon Arachnie, I have the sneeking suspicion that it could be used to good effect but I havn't played around with it enough to develop a strategy with it.
I think this is fine, I really like the Cylon ships and frankely it's not priced bad I just don't want the steady release of increasingly lackluster ships at $4.99 pricepoints to become the norm. The dev team have already impressed me a lot with how this game has been refined since launch day but there's still alot to do, I'm willing to put down money for worthwile DLCs like this but what I really want is a Cylon Campaign or an expansion into the 2nd Cylon war.