Clearly these were designed to be promo pieces for Nier Replicant, and extra treats for those who have already beaten the game. This is not a DLC for day one players in my opinion! This is the type of DLC you get when you've beaten the game, and want to donate 10 bucks to thank the developers for the experience and get a little kick back. That or its best fit for people who played Replicant FIRST, and want to experience the same outfits in Automata.
THAT BEING SAID.
2B's lingerie is goofy and really doesn't make sense. Her colesseum doesn't make sense, it should be in the city ruins.
9S's outfit is alright, but does not fit his personality. His colesseum doesn't make sense, it should be desert.
2A's winter armor is confusing, there is no snow map. Her colesseum doesn't make sense, it should be forest.
The CEO battle should be in a separate colesseum with all S rank choices, and in a location such as the Department elevator or Emils Cave.
Plato's side mission is not replayable, i found it impossible (i lost), play it once and its done, not only that but the actual him freaking out and killing everyone was in the text story, but i did not experience that how i played it - and due to no replay factor - i won't unless i play the entire playthrough again (so far i am at 9 or 3 playthroughs however you see it) or starting a bare new game. but you can watch the music video again. :(
Am i glad i got it, yes. i still love this game, i am critical because i love this game. maybe one day i will get a chance to work for a major game studio and have authority to help deliver a complex and inviting story with even MORE replayability. I am 100%ing this game anyways but along the way i have many criticisms which i feel should be valuable feedback for SquareEnix.