Rating: 9/10 (Outstanding)
NieR: Automata is a beautifully unconventional masterpiece that combines thought-provoking storytelling, dynamic combat, and hauntingly atmospheric music. It’s an unforgettable journey, though not without a few rough edges.
What I Loved:
A Story That Stays With You:
NieR: Automata tells a deeply philosophical and emotional story that explores themes of purpose, existence, and what it means to be human. It’s a narrative full of twists and layered with meaning, encouraging you to reflect long after the credits roll (and trust me, they’ll roll more than once). The game’s multiple endings and branching paths add even more depth, revealing new layers of the story with each playthrough.
Dynamic and Stylish Combat:
The combat, designed by PlatinumGames, is fluid, fast-paced, and incredibly satisfying. You’ll seamlessly transition between melee attacks and ranged shooting, with each encounter feeling like a carefully choreographed dance. The ability to customize your character with plug-in chips adds a strategic element, allowing you to tailor the experience to your preferred playstyle.
Unique Gameplay Variety:
NieR: Automata isn’t just an action RPG—it’s a genre-blending marvel. One moment you’re hacking and slashing, the next you’re piloting a mech in a shoot-’em-up segment, or navigating through a text-adventure sequence. This constant shift keeps the gameplay fresh and engaging throughout.
Unforgettable Music and Atmosphere:
The game’s soundtrack is nothing short of breathtaking. Each track, composed by Keiichi Okabe, perfectly complements the game’s melancholic yet hopeful tone. The combination of haunting vocals and orchestral arrangements makes every moment feel emotionally charged and significant.
Thoughtful World Design:
The post-apocalyptic world of NieR: Automata is hauntingly beautiful. While it’s not the most graphically advanced, the art direction makes every location feel meaningful, from the desolate city ruins to the eerie amusement park. The world design serves the narrative, often reflecting the emptiness and longing of its inhabitants.
What I Didn’t Love:
Occasionally Repetitive Gameplay:
While the combat is excellent, some segments—especially during repeat playthroughs—can feel repetitive. Certain side quests and areas require backtracking, which can slow the pace of an otherwise tight experience.
Sparse Open World:
The open world, while thematically appropriate, can feel barren at times. Fast travel is introduced later in the game, making early exploration feel like a bit of a slog. A few areas could have used more environmental storytelling or meaningful interactions.
Underdeveloped Side Quests:
While some side quests are poignant and add depth to the narrative, many are simple fetch quests or lack meaningful impact on the story. Considering the overall ambition of the game, the side content feels uneven in quality.
A Learning Curve for New Players:
NieR: Automata’s unconventional structure can be confusing for first-time players. It requires multiple playthroughs to see the full story, which might not appeal to everyone. The true brilliance of the game only becomes clear if you’re willing to commit to its unique format.
Overall Thoughts:
NieR: Automata is a game that defies convention, delivering an experience that’s as thought-provoking as it is fun. Its combination of stylish combat, genre-blending gameplay, and a deeply emotional narrative makes it stand out as one of the most memorable RPGs of its generation. While some repetitive elements and underdeveloped side quests hold it back from perfection, the sheer ambition and artistry of the game more than make up for its flaws.
Pros:
Deep and philosophical storytelling with multiple layers.
Fluid and satisfying combat with great customization options.
A hauntingly beautiful soundtrack that elevates every moment.
Genre-blending gameplay keeps things fresh and engaging.
Unique and memorable world design.
Cons:
Repetitive gameplay in certain sections.
Sparse open world with occasional pacing issues.
Side quests vary in quality and impact.
Unconventional structure may alienate some players.
Recommendation:
NieR: Automata is a must-play for fans of action RPGs and those who appreciate games with deep, existential themes. It’s a journey that rewards patience and curiosity, delivering an experience that’s as moving as it is fun. If you’re ready for a game that dares to be different, this is one you won’t forget.